3 MIN. READ

Air Fryer vs. Oven: The Great Debate Over Your Favorite Crispy Potatoes

iStock/CulinaryPhotography

Ah, the humble potato. A versatile, delicious staple that’s been part of our lives since… well, since forever. Whether they’re mashed, roasted, or baked, potatoes are a comfort food classic. But for many of us, the ultimate potato experience is a crispy, golden-brown one. The question is: are our favorite crunchy spuds still a healthy choice?

The Crispy Conundrum

For decades, the go-to method for making crispy potatoes has been deep frying. While it delivers that irresistible crunch, it also soaks the potatoes in oil, turning a simple spud into a calorie and fat bomb. Oven baking is often hailed as the healthier alternative, but let’s be honest—it often requires a generous glug of oil to get that perfect crisp, not to mention a long bake time.

But here’s the real head-scratcher: both deep frying and oven baking can create a compound called acrylamide. This is a substance that forms when starchy foods are cooked at high temperatures. While studies on its effects are ongoing, many health organizations recommend limiting your intake of foods with high acrylamide levels. It seems we can’t get that golden-brown color without a little bit of trouble.

Is the Air Fryer the Hero We’ve Been Waiting For?

Enter the air fryer, the new superstar of kitchen gadgets. It promises all the crunch of deep frying without the vat of oil. It works by circulating superheated air around the food, cooking it quickly and evenly. Since you only need a little bit of oil (or none at all), it’s been touted as the healthiest way to make your favorite fried foods.

And the science seems to back this up.

  • Reduced Calories and Fat: By using little to no oil, air frying can cut the calorie and fat content of your food significantly.
  • Lower Acrylamide: One study found that air frying could reduce the amount of acrylamide in potatoes by up to 90% compared to traditional frying.

 

Trendy kitchen gadget air fryer machine cooking deep-fried potato. Lifestyle of new cooking, small countertop convection oven, deep fast frying oil free, more healthful way to cook deep-fried food
iStock/almaphoto

But here’s where it gets a little complicated. A different study found that air-fried potatoes actually had the highest levels of acrylamide, even more than deep-fried ones. The researchers noted that the differences weren’t significant, and more research is needed to settle the debate. So, the jury is still out.

The Sensible Spud Strategy

So, what’s a crispy-potato lover to do? You don’t have to give up your favorite snack entirely. The key is to be a bit more mindful about how you prepare them.

  • Soak It Up: Before you cook them, soak your raw potato slices in water for about 30 minutes. This simple trick can help reduce acrylamide formation.
  • Take It Easy: Cook at a lower temperature for a longer period. And here’s the best part: pull them out of the oven or air fryer once they’re a lovely golden yellow, not a deep brown.
  • Shake, Rattle, and Roll: When using an air fryer, don’t just set it and forget it! Give the basket a good shake halfway through to ensure even cooking and maximum crispness.

 

Takeaway

The bottom line? There’s no need to banish potatoes from your plate. Whether you’re a fan of the air fryer or a traditionalist, a few small changes to your cooking routine can help you enjoy your favorite comfort food without the added worry.

 

Source:

The Healthiest Way To Cook Crispy Potatoes

Share the Post:

Active Aging News

Weekly Newsletter

RELATED NEWS

Close-up photo of a senior gray-haired woman standing outside in a park and wiping her nose with a napkin, suffering from a runny nose and seasonal allergies

How to Tackle Histamine Intolerance Naturally

2025-2030 USDA dietary guidelines for Americans

The “No-Brainer” Diet: Why the Government Finally Flipped the Food Pyramid

varieties of salads in front of white background

The 50+ Guide to Leafy Longevity: Which Lettuce Packs the Most Punch?

Female bare feet with weight scale

The Difference Between “Losing Weight” and “Losing Health” After 50

Jessie Diggins holding skis next to image og Salmon MIso Grain Bowl

The Olympic Recovery Secret: Why This 10-Minute Salmon Bowl is a Game-Changer After 50

OTHER STORIES

Multiethnic group of friends having meal at diner restaurant

What We Can Learn From Gen Z’s Sober Lifestyle

Doctor, patient and tablet for x ray with knee, screen and osteoporosis with point at hospital. People, application and medical consultation for arthritis, feedback and report for wellness at clinic

The Silent Secret: Why 1 in 4 People Don’t Know They’re Being Treated for Osteoporosis

ClassPass 2024 Year in Review

2024 Fitness and Wellness Trends and What’s Next for 2025

Bottle pouring virgin olive oil in a bowl close up

Olive Oil: An Ancient Elixir for Modern Health

Overweight Man performing lunge

Is Creatine the Missing Link in the Obesity Puzzle?

Retirement, fitness and walking with dog and couple in neighborhood park for relax, health and sports workout. Love, wellness and pet with old man and senior woman in outdoor morning walk together

Ditch 10,000: Why 6,000 Steps Is Your New Walking Goal

[chatbot style="floating"]

Please enter your email to access your profile