• 3 MIN. READ

Should Losing Weight or Exercising Be Your Goal?

iStock/SeventyFour

We all want to be fit and trim. Usually in that order. How many of us remember Twiggy from the 60’s or Kate Moss from the 90’s? Super models who exemplified the meaning of being thin, but realistically, who few women wanted to emulate. No, being trim without being fit is not an attractive goal. So what about being fit without being trim? That’s for more achievable, right? “Yeah, but unless I lose the weight my risk of cardiovascular disease will still be high. Won’t it?”

The Research

Not so fast Sherlock. A recent study in the British Journal of Sports Medicine discovered a very interesting observation. People who are aerobically fit, i.e. those who perform some sort of cardiorespiratory fitness (CRF), have a significantly reduced risk of premature death due to cardiovascular disease even if they are obese.

Yep, you read it correctly. Obese people who exercised were just as likely as non-obese people who exercised of dying due to cardiovascular disease. Or, another way to look at it is, thin people, or even people with normal BMI’s who do not exercise, are almost 2-3x more likely of dying due to cardiovascular disease then obese people who do exercise.

“This tells us that it’s much more important, all things considered, to focus on the fitness aspect” of health and longevity, “rather than the fatness aspect,” Siddhartha Angadi, senior author of the study and an exercise physiologist at the University of Virginia, told The Washington Post.

The review pooled data from 20 prior studies involving nearly 400,000 midlife and older adults from multiple countries, about 30% of whom were women.

Participants were grouped based on their aerobic fitness, which was objectively measured through cardiovascular stress tests, and their body mass index (BMI).

The findings were clear:

  • People who were fit and overweight or obese had similar risks of death as fit people at a normal weight
  • But people who were unfit — no matter their weight — had 2 to 3 times higher risks of dying early from any cause or heart disease

 

“From a statistical standpoint, fitness largely eliminated the risk” of early death from obesity-related conditions, Angadi said.

And it doesn’t require that much an effort to be considered fit. Even moving slightly higher than the bottom 20% of fitness for someone’s age can offer substantial health benefits. Even going for brisk walks where you can talk but not sing, is enough to boost your fitness accordingly.

Takeaway

So maybe don’t skip that trip to Gino’s Pizzeria (at least on the weekend), but definitely hit the treadmill, stair master, or rowing machine come Monday morning 😊.

 

Source:

Cardiorespiratory fitness, body mass index and mortality: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Fitness Matters More Than Weight for Longevity, Study Says

Share the Post:

Active Aging News

Weekly Newsletter

RELATED NEWS

Happy group of senior people smiling at camera outdoors - Older friends taking selfie pic with smart mobile phone device - Life style concept with pensioners having fun together on summer holiday

The $100 Million Contest To Make Us Feel Young Again

Senior man using medical device to measure blood pressure

Why Your Bottom Blood Pressure Number Matters More Than You Think

Picture showing steps and scoring for sit and rise test

The “Sit-Rise” Test: A Window into Your Health

Sleepy woman stirring coffee in the morning

Ozempic for Sleep?

Green powder with green capsules on white background.

The Next Generation of Weight Control: Why Tiny Tea Beads Might Be Your New Diet Hero

OTHER STORIES

Black woman, breath and hand on chest, for meditation and wellness being peaceful to relax. Bokeh, African American female and lady outdoor, in nature and being calm for breathing exercise and health

The Mind-Body Connection: How Mental Toughness May Add Years to Your Life

Aroma, cooking and mature woman in kitchen in home with smelling dinner, meal or dish. Happy, pot and female person with satisfaction for scent of supper with health, wellness and nutrition in house.

You’ve Earned the Right to Good Taste: How to Spice Up Your Food Now That Your Body Only Tolerates the Truth

Guided Imagery

Relax Your Mind and Body with Guided Imagery Meditation

At night, an elderly woman can be seen sleeping soundly in bed. She is covered with a blanket, and her arms are wrapped around a pillow. The bed is made with pink sheets and a pink blanket.

The Hidden Threat in Your Bedroom: Light Exposure and the Accelerated Risk of Heart Attack and Stroke

Savor the Sun: Crafting the Perfect Healthy Summer Meal

Active senior women with walking poles chatting outdoors and smiling

The Power Stroll: Simple Steps to Boost Your Daily Stroll

[chatbot style="floating"]

Please enter your email to access your profile